Columns

Editorial: Wasteful Disassembly

Automakers usually try to find the best way to assemble the cars they build. In a bizarre twist on this theme, Mazda has spent the past 2 years and probably millions of dollars figuring out how to destroy cars. Writing recently in The Wall Street Journal, Joel Millman explains that it all began in 2006 when the Cougar Ace, carrying 4,703 shiny new Mazda cars, nearly sank in the Pacific. The ship spent weeks adrift, listing at a 60-degree angle, before being righted and ultimately towed to Portland, OR.

What to do with the cars? Although most had remained securely in place, some broke free and sustained severe damage. Could the others be salvaged or was there irreparable damage from the prolonged and severe list? No one knew for sure. Millman reports, however, that there was no lack of interest in the vehicles. To the contrary, he says hundreds of people called about buying the cars. Schools wanted them for auto shop courses. Hollywood asked about using them for stunt vehicles.

Mazda turned them all away. Why? Mazda worried about getting sued if, for example, an air bag failed to fire correctly because of exposure to salty sea air. It also worried-with good reason-that scammers might move the cars abroad to sell as new. This happened with thousands of cars salvaged from the flooding that inundated New Orleans after hurricane Katrina. Those cars were unloaded in Latin America and problems with damaged electronics and engines hurt the carmakers’ reputations.

Mazda’s decision was to destroy $100 million worth of cars. Turns out, however, that isn’t as easy as it sounds. Mazda had to create a disassembly line, which took more than a year. The city of Portland, for example, wanted assurance that antifreeze, brake fluid, motor oil and other hazardous fluids wouldn’t be mishandled. Insurers covering Mazda’s losses wanted to be sure the company couldn’t resell parts on the side. So CD players are smashed, wheels are cut in two, air bags are discharged, and tires and batteries are destroyed.

This can’t have been an easy decision for Mazda, but the company felt it had no viable alternative. Given the vulnerability to product liability litigation, and the insurer’s reluctance to allow Mazda to recoup some of the loss by selling CD players and other perfectly good components, the company probably couldn’t have responsibly reached any other conclusion.

Even though much of the steel will be sent back to Asia and recycled, and one hopes that the precious metals will be salvaged from the catalytic converters, a great deal of the material is probably destined for landfills. This is tragic. We need to conserve resources and protect the planet. We cannot afford fear of tort law abuse to drive decisions like this that waste irreplaceable natural resources, engineering creativity and manufacturing capability.

Congress-and presidential candidates-take note!
Editorial Director Emeritus

Recent Articles by Don Hegland

You must register or login in order to post comments.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

Wire Harness

AssemTech Inc. is a busy and growing harness assembly shop in West Chicago, IL. The company has a 12,000-square-foot assembly area and employs 20 full-time harness assemblers - far cry from its early days back in 1986, when founder Chuck Hall and various family members assembled harnesses in his garage.

Podcasts

A Plan to Revive U.S. Manufacturing
In December, the nonpartisan Council on Competitiveness issued a landmark report, Make: An American Manufacturing Movement, that provides dozens of recommendations for addressing the many challenges facing U.S. manufacturers. In this podcast, Jack McDougle, the council’s senior vice president for manufacturing, discusses the council’s vision for reviving U.S. manufacturing. Check out this sneak preview of McDougle’s May 2 keynote address to start Tech ManufactureXPO.

More Podcasts

THE MAGAZINE

Assembly Magazine

may 2012 cover

2012 May

Check out Assembly's May issue!!

TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBSCRIBE

Lean Hang-Ups

By now, most assembly plants have at least tried lean manufacturing. But, some aspects of lean have been easier to implement than others. What tenet of lean has your assembly plant had the most trouble with?
See Poll Results Poll Archive

THE ASSEMBLY MAGAZINE STORE

welding.gif
Welding: Principles & Practices

This text introduces students to a solid background in the basic principles and practices of welding.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Assembly Showrooms

ASSEMBLY Showrooms

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter  LinkedIn  YouTube