Assembly Blog

Senior Editor

How to Get America Back on Track

February 03, 2009
Two previous U.S. presidents had the courage, vision and foresight to change the transportation landscape, and transform the economic climate, by spearheading mega-construction projects: the transcontinental railroad (Abraham Lincoln) and the interstate highway system (Dwight Eisenhower). The new Obama administration can make history by creating a world-class high-speed rail network in the United States.


Building a high-speed rail network would cost a ton of money, but it would also put an awful lot of people to work. Photo courtesy Siemens AG


The new Obama administration has its hands full addressing a wide range of issues and problems, ranging from the economy and the war to healthcare reform and no child left behind. There’s also lots of talk about rebuilding America’s infrastructure. Just this past week, the American Society of Civil Engineers said that after “decades of underfunding and inattention” the U.S. infrastructure needs no less than $2.2 trillion in repairs and upgrades.

We certainly need many new roads and bridges. Anyone who drives on Chicago-area streets this time of the year can attest to that. However, I would also urge the new team in Washington to start laying out a game plan that would establish a world-class high-speed rail network in the United States.

If you’ve ever travelled on the TGV in France or the Shinkansen in Japan, you know what I’m talking about-aerodynamic, electric-powered trains that travel smoothly, safely, quietly and efficiently from city to city at speeds up to 200 miles per hour.

Last November, California voters approved a proposition that may some day lead to a high-speed rail system connecting urban areas in the Bay Area, the San Joaquin Valley and Southern California. Similar proposals are under consideration in the Midwest and the Southeast.

Proponents of the California plan claim that more than 100 million passengers would ride their high-speed system by 2030. Without starting to make an investment today, tomorrow’s traffic congestion on highways will grow much worse and airport delays will intensify.

To serve the same number of passengers as the proposed train system, California would reportedly have to build 3,000 lane-miles of freeway, five airport runways and 90 departure gates. But, all that new infrastructure would come with a steep price tag-more than twice the construction cost and environmental impact as high-speed rail.

I realize that building a high-speed rail network would cost a ton of money. On the other hand, it would also put an awful lot of people to work. Perhaps the locomotives and rolling stock, not to mention signals, sensors and other communication equipment, could be built in one of the GM assembly plants recently shuttered in Dayton, OH, or Janesville, WI.

Two previous U.S. presidents had the courage, vision and foresight to change the transportation landscape, and transform the economic climate, by spearheading similar mega-construction projects. In the early 1860s, Abraham Lincoln championed the transcontinental railroad, which spurred rapid development in the agricultural, mining and manufacturing sectors. One hundred years later, Dwight Eisenhower’s interstate highway system paved the way for explosive growth in the automotive and trucking industries, not to mention the fast-food business and other spin-offs, such as suburban shopping malls.

After years of talk and no action on high-speed rail, it’s time to finally get America on the right track.

Thank you!

Marc
January 20, 2009 10:12 PM
It amazes me that this subject doesn't come up more often!!! We need to divert the Billions of dollars going towards the auto industry bailout and direct it towards public transportation, most notably high speed rail.


Mass Transit

www.productiontoolco.com
January 26, 2009 8:44 AM
Currently a large part of our country lives in wide spread rural areas. Developing a transit system to accommodate this type of layout would be extremely difficult. For now the maintenance of our auto industry is key to both transportation and our economy. To be successful mass transit should start in our major cities and grow from there.


a ton of money....

Paul
February 04, 2009 11:24 AM
Austin: where is the "ton of money" going to come from? If the answer is THE GOVERNMENT, no thank you. I don't want to spend my money in taxes to put "an awful lot of people to work." C'mon guys - the stuff doesn't grow on trees! If high speed rail is such a great deal, why hasn't a private business gone after it? Answer: it's a money loser, and won't work without government subsidies.


High Speed Rail

Joel melnick
February 04, 2009 11:44 AM
There are so many trips that are too short to make flying worthwhile and too long to drive the roundtrip in one day. A rail option would be fantastic. Can you imagine if airports were linked by rail to each other and cities. Then when the weather or other delays occur you could use the trains. There is currently high rail usage from Albany, NY to NYC. The train is as fast as the car, no parking issues in NYC, frequent service and there is no way you fly this 2.5 hour route. Connecting to Rochester, NY or Portland, ME is mostly done by car and would be so efficient, comfortable and fast if frequent and fast rail service was in place. I applaud the idea. Please remember the true cost of oil is well over $7 per gallon according to Pentagon studies. If you didn't have to defend access to the oil fields it would save plenty of money for infrastructure. Why not plan ahead? Good commentary.


Expensive Too?

Mike
February 04, 2009 8:37 PM
"Developing a transit system to accommodate this type of layout would be extremely difficult." Aw, hell! You didn'tell me it was going to be difficult! Just forget it.


Roads cost a ton of money too....

Scott
February 05, 2009 9:11 AM
"Austin: where is the "ton of money" going to come from? If the answer is THE GOVERNMENT, no thank you." You forget that roads aren't a private business and we fund them to all ends. By the rational of your argument, we should privatize them and see where the investment will come from. It won't because it takes an entity, government in this case, to make it happen. Government does things that no private business can do profitably. That is their job. Scott


rail project

Paul
February 05, 2009 11:27 AM
Scott said, "You forget that roads aren't a private business and we fund them to all ends. By the rational of your argument, we should privatize them and see where the investment will come from. It won't because it takes an entity, government in this case, to make it happen." True, for the interstate system. However, many roads are private - they're called toll roads, and I believe they are very viable, so much so that even foreign companies desire to aquire them. I still argue that it is not the government's role to make jobs, but rather private enterprise. And, no one commenting here has answered where this ton of money is going to come from, because the answer is inconvenient: the money has to be taken from someone and given to this high-speed rail project. Even if there was consensus that a high-speed rail project was a great idea, then the government should do what you and I have to do when we want something: we have to set aside some of our income until we save enough to pay for it. Until then, we have to do without. Our national debt is staggering. You're not suggesting that we just pull out another credit card and spend "a ton" more, are you?


High Speed Rail

Tom
February 08, 2009 5:45 PM
Low population density is a poor argument against high speed rail. Spain has a similar population density to california and is building the world's biggest HSR network. Intercity transit is fundamentally different from city transit. And.. can you imagine a private company being able to finance a project of this scale and risk? The french TGV lines are profitable but the state retains control so it can reinvest in new lines and services. Better than a private company charging so much only the rich can use it.


Urban vs Suburban Issues

dwmcgill
February 27, 2009 11:03 AM
As practical as a high-speed rail system can be in Europe (for example), it would not be nearly as viable a solution in the US for several reasons, including two major ones: 1) Average destination distances and 2)urban city vs. suburban work centers. Travelling from Frankfurt to Koln, or Stuttgart to Kassel is great, but that doesnt' mean that I would choose that option for a Chicago to Denver connection


You must register or login in order to post comments.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

Wire Harness

AssemTech Inc. is a busy and growing harness assembly shop in West Chicago, IL. The company has a 12,000-square-foot assembly area and employs 20 full-time harness assemblers - far cry from its early days back in 1986, when founder Chuck Hall and various family members assembled harnesses in his garage.

Podcasts

Lighting and 3D: Their Impact on Vision Inspection
Cognex Corp. makes vision inspection systems for manufacturers worldwide. Recently, John Stamos, sales engineer for Cognex, spoke with Jim Camillo, a senior editor of Assembly magazine, about the impact of lighting and 3D technologies on current and future vision inspection systems. The interview was conducted after a small-group presentation by Stamos in Chicagoland.
More Podcasts

THE MAGAZINE

Assembly Magazine

February 2012 issue cover

2012 February

Assembly's new issue is now available. Check it out!

TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBSCRIBE

U.S. manufacturers

What are your plans for 2012?
See Poll Results Poll Archive

THE ASSEMBLY MAGAZINE STORE

welding.gif
Welding: Principles & Practices

This text introduces students to a solid background in the basic principles and practices of welding.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Assembly Showrooms

ASSEMBLY Showrooms

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter  LinkedIn