Assembly Blog


Rolling Stones and Root Causes

October 5, 2012

Mick Jagger of the Rolling Stones famously sang:

You can’t always get what you want
But if you try sometimes,
You just might find
You get what you need

While I doubt Mr. Jagger had anything remotely near assembly automation in mind when he wrote those lyrics, they apply surprisingly well. In my 15 years of designing and building custom automation, I have found that manufacturers often focus on solving the problem at hand, rather than looking at the root cause of the issue. It is human nature to want to solve what appears to be the immediate issue. However, it makes little sense to frantically mop up a flooded house while the faucet remains wide open. In the end, it’s a losing and costly proposition.

A good example of this type of thinking is to draw arbitrary lines between the various stages of a manufacturing process. By focusing on individual processes, engineers lose control of the orientation of a part from one stage to the next.

I recall a manufacturer who called us in to help automate several steps in its process. The manufacturing engineer showed me an assembly operation where the operator picked a complex-shaped part out of a box. The operator then spent several seconds flipping the part over in her hands to determine the correct orientation before placing it into an assembly fixture.

When I inquired why it took so long, the engineer explained that the part was “almost, but not quite symmetrical,” and it was difficult to determine the proper orientation. The engineer had even investigated orientating the part by vibratory feeder bowl, but found that it was expensive and not 100 percent reliable. The engineer wanted a vision system that would tell the operator if the part was oriented correctly. This was imaginative and technically possible. But, it was what the engineer wanted. It wasn’t necessarily what he needed.

I asked to see the process just prior to the assembly operation. The engineer protested, stating that was not the issue. I persisted and eventually was led to an injection molding machine where the parts were being made and then ejected randomly into a bucket. This was the root cause. The molding machine obviously controls the orientation of the parts. Once we have control of orientation, we never want to let it go. In the end, we proposed to pull the parts out of the molding machine and place them into trays, so the orientation was controlled and repeatable. This eliminated the need for operators to orient the parts and reduced a 15-second cycle time on the downstream machine to 6 seconds.

Despite the popularity of Six Sigma, kaizen events and lean manufacturing, I still see a distinct lack of root-cause analysis being performed in manufacturing. The fast-paced, demanding schedule of product development and deployment often blinds us to the real source of problems in our assembly plants. However, taking a step back to determine “what we need” rather than “what we want” can make a big difference in producing an efficient, economical and satisfactory automation solution.

Do you agree? Have you ever been blind to the root cause of a manufacturing problem? Did you ever get what you needed rather than what you wanted? Or vice versa? How would you have solved the customer’s problem? Share your thoughts!


Sean Dotson, PE, is the president and co-founder of RND Automation & Engineering, a manufacturer of custom industrial automation and robotic assembly machinery in Sarasota, FL. Visit www.rndautomation.com for more information.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Prevent the problem in the first place

Robert
October 11, 2012
I have experienced the same exact scenario as described by Sean. Too often, customers become myopic in the pursuit of a solution and want to focus only on “solving the problem,” which is usually whatever they are pointing at. Using root cause to look at the previous processes can often yield very positive results. Simply stated, rather than focus on how we are going to separate the fly poop from the pepper, let’s see if we can prevent the condition in the first place!

Edward
October 18, 2012
I have often seen customers, designers and sales associates blinded by appearance of a product without considering whether the product was designed to be assembly-machine-friendly. Yes, automation engineers can provide a lot of electronics, mechanics, and articulating voodoo to give them results. However, simplicity in design and part handling will always prevail. The root cause of the problem may very well be the product itself.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

Behind the Scenes at Ford's Michigan Assembly Plant

People are the heart and soul of the 2012 Assembly Plant of the Year. This slideshow shows some of the men and women who build three different types of electrified vehicles alongside traditional gas-powered cars on the auto industry’s most flexible assembly line—Ford’s Michigan Assembly Plant in Wayne, MI. Photos courtesy Ford Motor Co.

Podcasts

Live from The Assembly Show, the hosts of Manufacturing Revival Radio sit down with Adam Malofsky, Ph.D., president and CEO of Bioformix to discuss his company’s innovative, energy-saving adhesives and polymers, which cure without the need for heat or light. 

More Podcasts

THE MAGAZINE

Assembly Magazine

april assembly cover

2014 April

The 2014 April Assembly includes a cover story about robots and small manufacturers plus much more. Check it out today!
Table Of Contents Subscribe

Immigration Reform

Could immigration reform benefit U.S. manufacturers?
View Results Poll Archive

THE ASSEMBLY MAGAZINE STORE

welding.gif
Welding: Principles & Practices

This text introduces students to a solid background in the basic principles and practices of welding.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Assembly Showrooms

ASSEMBLY Showrooms

STAY CONNECTED

facebook_40px twitter_40px  youtube_40pxlinkedin_40px